Goat Milk Formula and Infant Sleep Duration

    Adequate sleep is crucial for infant health and development. Research indicates that babies who consistently get sufficient sleep show improved growth by six months. Conversely, infants who sleep less may face increased risks, including higher body fat levels, delayed cognitive development, and challenges with emotional regulation during their early years.

    Infant sleep quality also significantly impacts parents. Even a loss of just 30 minutes of sleep per night can negatively affect daily life for both the baby and parents, increasing maternal fatigue and the risk of depression. Consequently, many families actively seek strategies to enhance their infants’ sleep.

    In addition to behavioral techniques, nutritional choices are believed to influence sleep patterns, although current studies yield mixed results. Breastfed babies commonly wake more often and sleep less at night compared to those fed formula. This difference is often attributed to breast milk being digested faster than cow milk-based formula, potentially leading to more frequent awakenings. However, not all research confirms a clear link between feeding type and sleep duration.

    Although breastfeeding offers numerous proven health benefits for both infants and mothers, exclusive breastfeeding rates in Europe remain low, with only around 13% of infants exclusively breastfed for the first six months. As formula feeding becomes increasingly prevalent, goat milk-based formulas have emerged as an alternative. However, data on how goat milk formula influences infant sleep compared to cow milk formula and breast milk remains limited.

    This study analyzed sleep duration and night awakenings among infants fed goat milk formula (GMF) versus cow milk formula (CMF), using breastfed infants as a reference group. The data were sourced from a randomized controlled trial conducted across Germany, Spain, Austria, and Croatia from July 2015 to May 2018.

    The original trial involved 304 healthy, full-term newborns aged between 1 and 14 days, randomly assigned to exclusively receive either GMF (Kabrita™) or CMF (Enfamil™). A comparison group consisted of exclusively breastfed infants. Over 112 days, parents completed detailed 3-day sleep diaries before each of six clinic visits (on days 0, 14, 28, 56, 84, and 112), documenting sleep patterns, health status, and potential feeding issues.

Sleep Duration Findings:

Total Sleep: Although overall sleep slightly decreased with age for all infants, CMF-fed babies consistently slept the least. Significant differences were noted at certain visits, where GMF-fed and breastfed infants slept about 30-40 minutes more compared to CMF-fed infants.

Daytime Sleep: CMF-fed infants consistently had the shortest daytime naps. GMF-fed infants slept approximately half an hour longer on average than CMF-fed babies throughout the study, with especially pronounced differences noted during the middle visits of the trial.

Nighttime Sleep: Nighttime sleep slightly increased with age for all groups, with minimal overall differences. Notably, after about three months, breastfed infants began sleeping less at night and woke more frequently than formula-fed babies.

Possible Explanations:

    The longer daytime sleep durations observed among GMF-fed infants may relate to goat milk’s nutritional profile. Goat milk is easier to digest due to its protein composition, which includes less α-s1-casein, more β-casein, and larger casein micelles compared to cow milk. These differences might facilitate faster gastric emptying and improve comfort, contributing to better daytime sleep.

    Interestingly, despite similar digestibility between goat milk and human milk, GMF-fed infants did not experience more frequent night awakenings like breastfed babies. This suggests that digestion alone does not fully explain night-waking patterns. Additional factors, such as feeding practices and parental responsiveness, may significantly influence nighttime sleep behaviors.

Takeaway for Parents:

    Sleep plays a crucial role in infant development, impacting physical growth, cognitive skills, and emotional regulation. How a baby is fed—whether breast milk, goat milk formula, or cow milk formula—can significantly influence sleep patterns.

    Babies fed goat milk formula tend to have longer daytime sleep periods compared to those fed cow milk formula. Their sleep patterns align more closely with breastfed infants, suggesting potential advantages in comfort and digestion associated with goat milk.

    Differences in the protein composition of goat milk and cow milk may play a significant role in these sleep outcomes, possibly offering parents an alternative formula option that supports better sleep and overall infant well-being.

Reference:

van Lee L, Meijer-Krommenhoek Y, He T, van der Zee L, Verkade H. Sleep duration among breastfed, goat milk-based or cow's milk-based infant formula-fed infants: Post hoc analyses from a double-blind RCT. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2025 Mar;80(3):482-489. doi: 10.1002/jpn3.12436. Epub 2024 Dec 19. PMID: 39698907; PMCID: PMC11874161.

Photo by Lucas Margoni on Unsplash